Firm News

Workers' Compensation Audits: Ensuring Compliance And Cost Efficiency For Employers

In its 2026 Executive Budget, the Workers’ Compensation Board of New York reaffirmed its commitment to protecting the rights of both employees and employers. The budget called for $232 million in Special Revenue Funds, funded by assessments on businesses in the Empire State. Employers in New York must pay these assessments as part of their standard premiums, and they go directly to the Workers’ Compensation Board (WCB). In order to ensure employers pay correct assessments and premiums, insurers implement mandatory workers’ compensation audits. Because the WCB aims to protect both employees and employers, these workers’ compensation audits can help companies avoid both underpayments and overpayments. 

Those approaching these audits for the first time may work with experienced employment law attorneys in New York, especially if disputes arise. Founded in 2007, Schwab & Gasparini provides tailored representation to New York companies. Our workers’ compensation lawyers can work in tandem with in-house counsel, human resources professionals, and upper management during audits. Attorneys Victor Aqeel and Jacob Schwartz both have strong backgrounds in workers’ compensation matters. Contact our Albany location at (518) 591-4664, our Syracuse Office location at (315) 422-1333, our Hudson Valley location at (914) 304-4353, or our White Plains location at (914) 304-4353. 

Is Record-Keeping Important for Workers’ Compensation Audits?

New York requires employers to go through regular workers’ compensation audits. In-person audits may be required at least every three years, although other types of insurance renewals can occur virtually or by mail. Efficient record-keeping is important during this process, as employers may need to provide extensive information to auditors. The most obvious way to streamline this process is to keep adequate records before the audit even begins. When approaching workers’ compensation audits, employers may also want to review existing records, such as those regarding ownership structures and employee classifications (contractor vs. employee). 

Summary of Workers’ Compensation Audit Compliance

Workers’ compensation audits in New York are mandatory insurance reviews designed to ensure that employers pay accurate workers’ compensation premiums and comply with reporting requirements established by the New York Workers’ Compensation Board and the New York Compensation Insurance Rating Board.

• A workers’ compensation audit typically occurs at the end of a policy period and allows insurers to review payroll records, tax documents, employee classifications, and subcontractor insurance documentation to verify that premiums were calculated correctly.
• Employers paying annual premiums of $10,000 or more generally undergo in-person audits every year, while those paying less may experience physical audits every three years, along with annual payroll reporting requirements.
• Maintaining organized records, including payroll documents, tax filings, and worker classification documentation, can help streamline the audit process and reduce the likelihood of fines, disputes, or incorrect premium adjustments.

Schwab & Gasparini provides legal guidance related to workers’ compensation compliance for employers throughout New York, including Albany, Syracuse, the Hudson Valley, and White Plains.

What Is a Workers’ Compensation Audit?

A workers’ compensation audit is a mandatory review that insurers oversee at the end of a policy period in New York. The purpose of this process is to review information to ensure accurate premiums. Depending on the outcome of the audit, an employee might need to pay increased or decreased premiums in the future. Premiums might also remain the same after a review of this information. If the information shows that the employer overpaid, a refund may be necessary. During an in-person audit, an auditor may arrive at the workplace or a remote office. A staff member will need to assist the auditor as they gather and review various documents. Staff members might also need to answer any questions the auditor has during this process. 

How Often Do In-Person Workers’ Compensation Audits Occur in New York?

According to the New York Compensation Insurance Rating Board, physical (in-person) audits must occur on a regular basis for many employers. The frequency of these physical audits depends on the circumstances of each employer. If an employer pays an annual premium of $10,000 or more, it must go through a workers’ compensation audit every year. This means that most major enterprises in New York will need to plan for this process as part of their normal year-end processes. 

If an employer pays less than $10,000 in premiums annually, it must submit to a physical audit within the first year of a new policy. Subsequently, physical audits are only required once every three years for employers of this type. However, these employers must still submit signed payroll statements each year. The Insurance Rating Board also notes that it may waive in-person audit requirements for employers with premiums under $10,000 if accessing the physical business premises would be “impractical.” Examples include operations with only one or two employees, or businesses operated out of private residences. Finally, in-person audits are not required if the business pays $1,500 per year or less in premiums. 

What Records Do I Need to Prepare for a Workers’ Compensation Audit in New York?

An auditor will need to review various documents during this process. These include payroll statements, ledgers, and tax documents. If an employer works with subcontractors, they may need to provide certificates of insurance. Employers may also need to provide documents that help establish the classifications of their workers. For example, an employer might work with a mixture of employees and independent contractors. The distinction between these two types of workers is important, as only employees are covered by workers’ compensation. 

Employers should remember that misclassifying employees as independent contractors is a violation of New York employment law. As a result, it makes sense to carefully consider accurate worker classifications before a workers’ compensation audit. Schwab & Gasparini may be able to help employers determine whether to classify a worker as an employee or independent contractor before audits begin. If employers fail to provide certain records, they may face fines from the WCB. Payroll documents are particularly important when calculating future premiums. 

Learn More About Workers’ Compensation Audits With Schwab & Gasparini

Workers’ compensation audits can be challenging, whether an organization is new to this process or has gone through many audits in the past. However, these audits can also be helpful in certain circumstances, as they have the potential to reduce premiums going forward. Although efficiency during the audit itself is important, employers must also strive to keep accurate records before this process even begins. Without these records, the audit process will almost certainly be more challenging. 

Mistakes and missing records not only have the potential to make workers’ compensation audits more time-consuming, but they can also make this process more costly due to fines and increased legal fees. As a result, many companies choose to work with experienced employment law attorneys in New York. Consider expanding on this topic with guidance from Schwab & Gasparini. Contact our Albany location at (518) 591-4664, our Syracuse Office location at (315) 422-1333, our Hudson Valley location at (914) 304-4353, or our White Plains location at (914) 304-4353. 

Important Frequently Asked Questions About Workers’ Compensation Audits

The following frequently asked questions provide additional information about workers’ compensation audits and employer compliance in New York.

What Is A Workers’ Compensation Audit?

A workers’ compensation audit is a mandatory review conducted by an insurer at the end of a policy period to verify that an employer paid the correct workers’ compensation insurance premiums. Auditors typically review payroll records, financial documents, and worker classifications to determine whether premiums should remain the same, increase, decrease, or result in a refund.

Why Do Workers’ Compensation Audits Occur In New York?

Workers’ compensation audits help insurers verify that employer premiums accurately reflect payroll totals, employee roles, and operational risks. The process supports compliance with requirements established by the New York Workers’ Compensation Board and ensures businesses do not underpay or overpay workers’ compensation premiums.

How Often Do In-Person Workers’ Compensation Audits Occur?

Employers with annual workers’ compensation premiums of $10,000 or more typically undergo in-person audits every year. Businesses with lower premiums may experience physical audits less frequently, although they must still submit annual payroll documentation and may undergo an in-person review every three years.

What Documents Are Required During A Workers’ Compensation Audit?

Auditors commonly review payroll records, general ledgers, tax filings, and financial statements. Employers may also need to provide certificates of insurance for subcontractors, documentation verifying worker classifications, and records confirming payroll totals for the relevant policy period.

Why Is Accurate Worker Classification Important During An Audit?

Worker classification determines whether an individual qualifies as an employee covered under workers’ compensation or as an independent contractor. Misclassifying workers may violate New York employment law and could result in financial penalties or incorrect premium calculations during an audit review.

What Happens If Records Are Missing During A Workers’ Compensation Audit?

Missing or incomplete records may delay the audit process and could result in estimated payroll calculations, higher premiums, or financial penalties. Maintaining organized payroll documentation and classification records helps ensure that auditors can accurately review employer obligations.

How Can Employers Prepare For A Workers’ Compensation Audit?

Employers may prepare for audits by maintaining organized payroll documentation, updating tax records, confirming worker classifications, and preserving insurance certificates for subcontractors. Consistent record-keeping throughout the policy period can simplify the audit process and reduce administrative burdens.

How Can Schwab & Gasparini Help Employers With Workers’ Compensation Audits?

Employers seeking additional guidance may consider visiting with an experienced attorney at Schwab & Gasparini to learn more about workers’ compensation compliance and audit preparation. Attorneys at the firm work to ensure that employers understand regulatory requirements, documentation expectations, and potential legal considerations related to workers’ compensation audits in New York.

Sun Apr 19 2026, 12:00am