Firm News

Creating Safe Reporting Systems For Workplace Harassment: Best Practices For Employers

Creating Safe Reporting Systems For Workplace Harassment: Best Practices For Employers

The business law attorneys at Schwab & Gasparini have been providing New York clients with experienced counsel for nearly two decades. We have four offices located across the state of New York, and we are proud to advise clients on employment law, as well as other matters central to efficient business practices. Creating safe reporting systems for workplace harassment is only one of many aspects of employer compliance that may help to limit your company’s risk exposure, and will likely have the greatest impact when integrated within a holistic approach to compliance throughout your organization. To discuss the details of state and federal employer compliance that relate directly to your own business circumstances, reach out to a member of our team in Albany (518-591-4664), Syracuse (315-422-1333), or White Plains and Hudson Valley (914-304-4353) today.

What Should Employers Know About Reporting Systems for Workplace Harassment?

Safe reporting systems for workplace harassment are essential, but the optimal structure for those systems will depend on the size and structure of the organization in which they are deployed. Best practices for employers are generally organized around strategies for making these reporting systems as readily accessible to employees as possible, while also protecting the worker’s privacy. To be effective, reporting systems will need to be integrated into a clear, detailed, legally compliant system for investigating reports and a fair, carefully documented framework for responding to their findings.

Summary

Creating safe reporting systems for workplace harassment is a key component of employer compliance under Equal Employment Opportunity Commission guidelines and New York State employment laws. Federal law defines workplace harassment as unwelcome conduct based on protected characteristics that creates a hostile, abusive, or intimidating work environment. New York State expands protected classes beyond federal standards, including categories such as gender identity, marital status, immigration status, and domestic violence survivor status. Effective reporting systems require multiple accessible channels, clear investigation protocols, and consistent documentation to demonstrate compliance during agency review. Schwab & Gasparini provides legal guidance to employers across New York State regarding workplace harassment compliance and reporting system implementation.

What Qualifies as Workplace Harassment?

Understanding the federal definition as well as the New York State regulatory guidance can provide employers with a solid starting point for crafting their internal company policies. Often examples can help employers recognize workplace conduct that might qualify as harassment, but because regulatory guidelines can use terms like “offensive” or “intimidation” that many employers might consider open to interpretation, it can be advantageous to get the perspective of an experienced business attorney to develop a framework for identifying how enforcement agencies at the state and federal level, and if necessary the courts, might apply these terms.

What Is the Legal Definition of Workplace Harassment?

As explained by USA.gov, federal law defines workplace harassment as conduct occurring in the workplace that is unwelcome to the person or persons at whom it is directed and that is based on the individual's color, sex, religion, race, older age, national origin, genetic information, or disability. Examples of harassment that may appear in the workplace include:

 

• Name-calling (including use of slurs)
• Physical assaults or threats
• Offensive jokes, or the presentation of offensive objects or images
• Intimidation

 

Harassment is always ugly, but it is only unlawful when conduct creates an environment in the workplace that is abusive, hostile, or intimidating, and the target of the harassment has to endure the conduct in order to maintain his or her employment.

What Is Considered Harassment in NYS?

The definition of harassment in New York State closely parallels the one used by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), but New York's list of protected classes is longer. In addition to the characteristics outlined under federal law, the Office of the New York State Attorney General lists the following categories as protected by law:

 

• Record of arrest or conviction
• Citizenship, or the employee's immigration status
• Gender identity or gender expression
• Sexual orientation
• Married or unmarried status
• "Family" status (the Attorney General's office gives pregnancy and having children as examples)
• Military status
• Status as victim or survivor of domestic violence

 

New York City maintains its own list of protected classes, in addition to those inherited from state and federal law.

 

Because there are so many categories, creating a separate policy for each of them may not be realistic at the level of day-to-day management (employees and managerial staff have to be able to remember the rules they are following and forcing, after all). Business attorneys therefore often recommend setting up internal protocols that are designed to ensure even-handed treatment across the board; if workplace harassment of all kinds is prohibited, then establishing and monitoring compliance with a complex set of discrete rules becomes unnecessary. A business lawyer with Schwab & Gasparini may be able to review your organization's needs and help you develop a policy that will be practical to implement while providing protection against liability.

Tips for Creating Safe Reporting Systems in Your Workplace

Efficient reporting systems are obviously not the only element of employer compliance with anti-harassment laws. However, establishing safe reporting systems that connect with a clear response protocol for the company to follow can be helpful in two ways:

 

1. Safe reporting systems employees know they can trust do make it more likely that your company will learn about possible instances of workplace harassment. As a company leader, you want this, even though receiving this type of report probably feels like getting bad news. You want these reports because they give your organization a chance to address the situation before it develops into a personnel or public relations crisis.
2. If your company becomes the subject of an external investigation by New York State or the federal EEOC, being able to show investigators that your company had safe reporting systems for workplace harassment, that you had a clear protocol for investigating reports and followed it throughout, can help to minimize your employer liability.

 

For all these reasons, it is important for leaders in a company to understand a few essential best practices for establishing and maintaining safe reporting systems.

Tip #1: Create Multiple Channels

Many employees will be familiar with the workplace wisdom that holds “HR is there to protect the company.” While some of these employees may conclude that the way HR is most likely to protect the company in their particular instance is through taking the report seriously and taking steps to remedy the situation, others will hesitate to report through your company’s human resources department. Reporting directly to the worker’s own manager can present a different set of problems, particularly if the manager is the person the employee wishes to report.

 

There is nothing wrong with allowing employees to report harassment to their managers, or directly to your company’s HR department, but in general you will need to have alternatives that are less likely to feel “confrontational” to an employee who already feels nervous and vulnerable. Remember that if there really has been harassment in your workplace, it will probably be accompanied by an erosion of the employee’s trust. At Schwab & Gasparini, we typically encourage clients to create reporting systems with multiple channels, and in some cases we may even recommend making one of these channels anonymous.

Tip #2: Make All Channels Accessible

No matter how carefully designed your reporting systems may be, they will not serve their purpose if employees are unable to access them, or unaware of the procedures for doing so. Make it a point to create clear channels for employees to formally report their concerns; in addition to any tools for submitting digital reports anonymously, this will likely mean also establishing a primary contact person for phone and in-person reporting, and possibly a secondary person who is authorized to take the same type of report in case the primary is part of the problem (or experiencing the problem!). Part of being accessible is being easy to find, so your employee onboarding materials, your handbook, and other similar tools used for setting expectations for workplace conduct and protocol should clearly state both what the reporting options are and how to begin the process.

Tip #3: Follow the Steps

There are reporting systems that can work even if they are not as frictionless as might be ideal. There are reporting systems that can work even if there are limited options for filing a complaint. There are no reporting systems that can work if the reports come in and sit in a file somewhere, gathering dust (or the digital equivalent). Employees need to believe that reporting will actually make a difference. Remember, you want your workers to report to you instead of proceeding directly to file a complaint with the EEOC or with New York authorities. You want to investigate and address any potential harassment at its root, so that even if there is an external investigation, it can only find that your organization had a clear, well-articulated protocol in place and followed it from start to finish.

Establish a Plan

There are two components to follow-through. The first is setting out in advance (for instance, in the employee handbook)the steps your company will take if a worker reports workplace harassment. Usually these steps will be centered on how the company will handle an investigation of the alleged conduct and what the company’s response will be if the investigation finds evidence that harassment has occurred, as well as what will happen if the investigation fails to substantiate the claims made in the initial report.

Commit to Execution

The second part of follow through is to actually carry out each step in the protocol already outlined, any time and every time an employee reports workplace harassment. Ideally, you will not have chances to demonstrate this type of commitment often, because the hope is that instances of harassment will not become an everyday occurrence, and your reporting systems may go long periods without needing to actually handle an employee complaint. However, it is very important that when a report is received, you not only follow each step of your defined protocol, but document the process as you go. This documentation can serve as evidence that your reporting systems have been effective, and that your organization has responded appropriately when those systems were used.

Build Your Reporting Systems With the Advice of a Skilled Attorney

Every organization with workers needs safe reporting systems in place for employees to report workplace harassment. Not only can such systems be important to employer compliance with state and federal anti-discrimination laws, but also they can help to foster employee trust and lay the groundwork for high employee morale and workplace harmony. Get help from our experienced New York business law team when you contact Schwab & Gasparini at any of our four convenient locations. You can find us at 518-591-4664 in Albany, at 914-304-4353 in Hudson Valley and White Plains, and at 315-422-1333 in Syracuse.

 

Fri Jun 5 2026, 12:00am