Firm News

The Role Of Confidentiality In Harassment Investigations: Legal Boundaries For Employers

Citizens of New York have a right to harassment free workplaces, and infringement on these rights may trigger harassment investigations in some circumstances. While these investigations can be intimidating and confusing for employees, they can present unique challenges for employers navigating harassment in their workplaces. No business owner wants to see unlawful conduct or discrimination in their company, but these infractions are common and difficult to predict. Understanding how to address them professionally and lawfully is key.

As such, employers may then wonder what role confidentiality plays in a harassment investigation. Many business owners’ first instincts will be to keep as much of the investigation private as possible, both to protect employees and the company's reputation. However, much legal nuance surrounds the issue of harassment in the workplace. While certain levels of confidentiality are appropriate and even necessary, other actions could be seen as a suppression of employee rights. Understanding how to tactfully navigate these tricky situations can require not only business acumen but legal experience.

Schedule a consultation with a New York labor and employment attorney from Schwab & Gasparini to discuss legal options for workplace harassment investigations. Call for a consultation with the Syracuse Office at (315) 422-1333, the Albany Office at (518) 591-4664, the White Plains Office at (914) 304-4353, or the Hudson Valley Office at (914) 304-4353.

New York Harassment Laws

Federal protections against harassment apply across the entire United States, but New York, in particular, has a much more stringent code against harassment. Understanding the unique legal climate in New York is the first step for employers toward effectively navigating harassment investigations. According to the New York State Attorney General, harassment is defined as any discriminatory act against an individual in a protected class. This can include several violations that may look different in each situation, including employment discrimination, offensive comments or behaviors, or even retaliation for speaking out. Harassment in the workplace can come from co-workers, employers, contractors, supervisors, and more. No individual in the workplace is exempt from these restrictions.

Additional Rules for Employers

Employers, however, may face more restrictions and regulations due to their position and authority over their employees. This increased authority also comes with increased accountability to the law. New York employers may face repercussions for discrimination against a wider range of people than a standard harassment offense. The higher level of accountability for employers means that diligence and intentionality may be required to avoid harassment claims. 

What Are Harassment Investigations?

A harassment investigation is generally a response from an employer regarding harassment allegations in the workplace. While investigations are generally handled within the company or with the support of outside legal counsel, failure to address these allegations could lead to a harassment complaint and legal action from the complainant. The process of harassment investigations often involves human resources managers or outside counsel conducting interviews of the relevant witnesses, the complainant, and the accused. For more complex or severe cases, legal counsel is often recommended to handle the legal nuances of the situation. 

For more information on how to conduct harassment investigations, speak with a seasoned New York labor and employment attorney from Schwab & Gasparini. 

Employer’s Responsibility During Harassment Investigations

The employer is generally expected to help navigate the process of a harassment investigation, due to their authority over the parties present and their representation of the company. While harassment charges and allegations may lead to legal consequences for the accused, this could also cause repercussions for the employer. Employers may be held responsible for enforcing legal standards and the company's anti-harassment policy and ensuring incidents do not occur. An employer may face legal repercussions if they are found negligent in enforcing or informing their employees of the relevant legal standards. 

How to Navigate a Harassment Investigation

Harassment investigations can be long and complex ordeals, which can be taxing on the company and challenging for employers. Each investigation will look different based on the allegation, size of the company, resources available, and many other factors. However, with experienced legal counsel, these obstacles can be overcome. Understanding the legal requirements, New York harassment policy, and proper evidence-gathering techniques can aid in this process. 

Respond Promptly

One of the first keys to effectively handling harassment allegations is to respond quickly. Not only does a late or halfhearted response communicate poor legal compliance, but it may also expose the employer to legal action for negligence. A prompt and clear response to the allegations can help resolve matters quickly and show a proper lack of tolerance for harassment in the workplace, potentially discouraging future infractions. Intervening quickly to help stop the actions leading to the complaints so that the complainant is protected while evidence is gathered.

Gather Evidence

Once the initial issue is addressed, the investigator may then begin to collect evidence to verify the harassment. Harassment is generally difficult to identify, as much of the evidence comes from witnesses, not from physical evidence. This is why interviews of eyewitnesses and taking statements are often the preferred method of gathering evidence. These interviews can help give the investigator a clear image of the situation, helping inform future decisions about the issue. During this process, it is generally recommended to retain confidentiality while also not suppressing employee rights. 

Corrective Action

Once the interviews are completed and a decision is made, employers are generally expected to play a role in corrective action. The action taken may depend on the verdict of the investigation as well as the severity of the harassment. For smaller infractions, employers may be expected to amend the behavior and provide disciplinary action. However, for severe cases such as sexual harassment or assault, the charges may be more severe in line with the New York Sexual Harassment Policy. Understanding how to provide accurate corrective action and to train employees to avoid harassment claims in the future is key to the longevity of a business. 

Speak to a New York Business Lawyer Today

Harassment investigations are overwhelming. Not only do they require work, effort, and attention, but they also introduce an element of uncertainty and fear for business owners. A harassment claim or lawsuit could severely damage the reputation of the business, but leaving issues unaddressed could damage employee morale and lead to more severe legal consequences down the road. Additionally, confidentiality must be balanced with employee rights while navigating the complexities of the harassment investigation process. All of these factors together can be overwhelming for business owners. Fortunately, a New York employment and labor law attorney can help address these concerns and provide effective legal counsel. Schedule a consultation today at (315) 422-1333 in Syracuse, the Albany Office at (518) 591-4664, the White Plains Office at (914) 304-4353, or the Hudson Valley Office at (914) 304-4353

Mon Nov 3 2025, 12:00am